First of all, as my rating suggests, I just want to say CLI is a great choice for a Chinese language school, which I doubt anyone could regret.
Under the guidance of my teachers in CLI, I managed to advance my Chinese level faster and further in a few months time than I ever did studying years before on my own and with private teachers. Getting to a point where I can speak and understand Chinese rather fluently.
In this spirit, I want to address some of the concerns I've had about the school when choosing it as my Chinese language school, in order to help those considering applying to this program:
1. Language school vs. University:
- The price of international language school programs is usually higher relative to university studies in China (but does usually include stuff like accomodation and visa support which may introduce additional fees going to China on a university program)
- Unlike university programs they usually don't award you with any official certificate of your studies.
I decided to go to a language school nontheless as my goal for studying Chinese in China was to become fluent in the language:
- Language school programs usually put a large focus solely on the language studies themselves, while in university programs at least 50% is usually dedicated to culture studies etc. (Nice to broaden your horizons but irrelevant for language learners like myself)
- Aside from that, as language schools are advertised for international students they offer a much better support in terms of visa applications, daily life and adjustment.
- I chose CLI specifically as I found their program offers all the support needed for a smooth transition, and all the facilities required for a comfortable life, saving me a lot of trouble in the end. Also, I was drawn by the cultural activities which, while not included in the price, compensate for some of the cultural orientation you may "lose" not choosing to study in a university program. All while still offering a lower price point relative to similar language schools.
2. The location of the school:
- This was a concern for me as Chinese language includes a range of dialects, out of which Manarin is the one spoken across China. I was afraid the teachers and/or locals in Guilin may use a different dialect in their daily lives which would end up with me adapting to a non-standard way of speech.
- Another concern which may apply for more casual learners looking to travel in their visit to China is that Guilin is quite far from some central cities like Beijing and Shanghai.
Thankfully, going through the programs I found none of these concerns have any expression in reality:
- Sure Guilin speech is a thing but it is not widely used in daily lives, and most people on the street and in school speak standard Mandarin. Also, CLI's teacher staff consists of both teachers from southern and northern China, giving you an opportunity to be exposed to the minor changes which occure in Mandarin across the land.
- Guilin itself is a tourist attraction, and has a bullet train station and an airport allowing for comfortable travel. Also, it offers a calmer environment compared to more central cities, which I found offers a better study environment and allows for a smoother adaptation process.
3. A program revolved around private lessons:
While the private lessons format provide great adaptability in pacing, focus etc, I was concerned about the downsides of it compared to group classes:
- It lacks a social aspect.
- You lose the opportunity of second hand learning which may open you up to new ideas.
I was, however, completely wrong to worry, as:
- CLI provides enough opportunities to support a social life along with the studies: the extra activities, shared meals, common areas and games.
- Second hand learning can happen all the time if you take initiative and use Chinese to engage with people.
- In hindsight I think learning in a group class could have decrease the efficiency and fluency of my lessons.
What other participants should know
- Your progress and adjustment will highly depend on your own self-descipline and will to communicate with your teachers and the staff (virtually every aspect is up for adjustment and negotiation but it has to come from you).
- Does not offer an official certificate of any kind on its own.
- The organizational aspect of the program could be improved, I experienced some mix ups with my application and during my stay (though everything worked out at the end without much excessive effort on my end).
Response from The Chinese Language Institute (CLI)
Hi Oleg! Thank you for taking the time to write a detailed and honest review. We're really glad your Comprehensive and Speaking & Listening classes worked well for you and that you were well looked after by our team.
With several years of Chinese behind you, your Reading & Writing lessons should have started from your current level, not radicals you already knew. We've talked it through with your teacher, and we're reminding every teacher on our team to check each student's level in the first lesson of each class and adjust from there.
The missed class on your last day was a scheduling mistake on our side, not the holiday (as you noted, we still offer lessons on holidays to students who request them). You should have heard from us before the lesson, not after. We're very sorry about this. The make-up lesson (plus the extra hour) is still yours whenever you'd like it. We've sent you a separate email to set this up.
Weekly room cleaning is included for every student, so we're looking into how your room was missed. And thank you for the kettle suggestion: we're putting one in every room.
Thank you again for studying with us and for helping us improve. 加油!